Pacquiao vs. Bradley: Why Matt Hamilton Scored It A Draw

Pacquiao vs. Bradley: Why Matt Scored It A Draw

Initial thoughts…

The 10-point must scoring system is far from a perfect one. It allows for fighters to accumulate rounds they have only won by the slightest of margins & penalizes them rather meekly for rounds in which they were utterly dominated. To be sure this was hardly vintage Pacquiao & whilst he was the far more definitive winner of rounds that he won than was Tim Bradley in the rounds he won – the scoring system as it stands will always be vulnerable to instances such as this one – but these are the rules, the rules both fighters abide by – judging is less about scoring a fight than about judging 4,6,8,10 or 12 rounds on their individual merits.

Additionally we should note that by being the busier fighter more or less throughout Bradley was always likely to take marginal rounds on the judges scorecards. And whilst his Compubox connect numbers (which I find frankly dubious at times) appear modest – he had a significant volume of “near miss” punches – punches thrown that might not have connected flush; though that did land partially – another source of potential favor in the eyes of judges who we should remember are viewing & judging the fight in real-time.

pacquiaobradleycompubox

Pacquiao vs. Bradley Compubox detailed version.

Second viewing.. 

Round 1

Bradley round – busier.

Round 2

Bradley round – busier.

Round 3

Clear Pacquiao round.

Round 4

Clear Pacquiao round, verging on a 10-8 round but I had it as a 10-9.

Round 5

Clear Pacquiao round. 10-9.

Round 6

Clear Pacquiao round. 10-9.

Round 7

Clear Pacquiao round. 10-9.

Round 8

Simply don’t concur with the Compubox tally on connects here – Bradley busier – Bradley 10-9.

Round 9

This round could have been scored any of three ways – 10-9, 9-10 or indeed 10-10. On the balance of it I believe Bradley took this round for the following reason – when Pacquiao misses he tends to “miss big” – that is a round in which his connect percentage is well off tends to be interpreted as a sloppy/wild road – so whilst busier, he didn’t have the volume of “near misses” evident in a round in which Bradley (typically) was busier – that is you get productive busy & sloppy busy – don’t shoot the messenger.

Round 10

Bradley round – same connects according to Compubox – Bradley busier.

Round 11

I had this as a rather more clear Bradley round – looking at these figures – assuming their accuracy there is a clear argument for a Pacquiao round – 15 vs 6 power connects. Hmmm…

Round 12

Again Bradley busier by 20 shots thrown – add to that a 11 vs 10 power connect situation & this is essentially a round that is either a 10-10 or a 10-9 for Bradley for me…

Thus, upon reflection, I’d give:

Bradley – Rounds 1,2, 8, 9, 10 & 12.

Pacquiao – Rounds 3,4,5,6,7 & 11.

Changes from live scoring – Round 11 & Round 9. 

Second viewing scoring: 114-114 Draw.

pacquiao-bradley-scorecard

Pacquiao vs. Bradley Official scorecards.

Some pre-fight thoughts…

Earlier pre-fight analysis on Pacquiao vs. Bradley

 

 

Matt Hamilton, for ESNewsReporting!

Matt Hamilton

Matt Hamilton on Boxing @ ESNewsReporting.com. Max Kellerman meets Simon Cowell.